Skip to content

Did McCain Napalm Women & Children during his ‘tour of duty’, and if so is he the best Candidate fo President?

While McCain doesn’t admit to it publicly, he could hardly be unaware of the massive civilian ‘collateral damage’ administered by the Cluster, Napalm and Incendiary bombing he let loose,
The celebrated journalist Harrison Salisbury, in a series of articles for the New York Times in 1966 described the effects of the Hanoi bombings on local civilians, noting that “small villages and hamlets along the route were almost obliterated”. Years later Mc Namara acknowledged that Operation ‘rolling Thunder’ (of which McCain, clocking up 23 missions was an enthusiastic participant) and which unloaded 800 tons of ordinance per day over North Vietnam, caused more than a million deaths and injuries each year from 1965 to 1968. While some of the Vietnamese army had access to an underground network of defensive tunnels civilians bore the brunt of the horrific airborne onslaught
ALL NEW POINTS WILL BE ANSWERED ASAP
Croxx your point is valid, and I would raise the very same objections if it were a WWII carpet bomber up for election – Ken in the spirit of open debate I am attempting to court answers for significant questions. Is this a problem ? – King Of Battle a poignant verse – EddyJ consider the long term objectives of the US military command and political control. The covert strategy to drain enemy morale by introducing carpet bombing techniques is nothing new. You dismiss the value of avoiding civilian casualties with almost frivolous contempt, do you feel the same way about the Americans who died on 9/11, or are they ‘special’? Personally I do believe that anyone who has ever abused or worse, killed a child isn’t fit to hold the post of President. That’s just me, and perhaps you don’t share the same value of human life. Yes McCain did serve’ in the US military, and not only knows the horror but actually created the horror for those that experienced the agony of his ‘brave’ bomb d
his ‘brave’ bomb dropping career, from the safety of 50.000 feet
Eric w makes some good and interesting revelations. I do think though, that moral aptitude is very important for the leadership role, so disagree with him on that point. Hot Couture your argument that the chain of command must be followed, and that this is the hallmark of a ‘strong individual’ is fallacious. It is precisely the ability to question a command, which defines the true strength of an individual’s character. This is justified when a command directs one to slaughter woman, children and old men. McCain’s failure to display such moral fortitude is a telling flaw Curtis B your racist attitude is a sad reflection on the insular and often nationalistic perspectives of your country
m1mike what’s for sure is that the aerial bombers engaged in operation ‘Rolling Thunder’, weren’t dropping leaflets, or flowers. If you look at any of the official records, the sheer tonnage of ordinance let loose is deeply depressing, and the results of their impact on the civilians receiving this generous American deposit aren’t too difficult to envisage. Your next point that Vietnam is to blame for its own bombardment is quite absurd. In London during WWII military departments and the ministry of defence were in and amongst urban city centres, as were anti aircraft placements, to protect civilians, but using your cold and pedantic ‘logic’ the Blitz was in fact the fault of Churchill. The point regarding carpet bombing is partially answered in the follow up to my original question when Salisbury describes the impact of a trail of bombing on the civilian settlements within as much as a mile of any target (see the new York times archives) and also Mc Namara’s statistical admissions
…admissions on Vietnam operations, (widely available government information). You miss the sarcasm inherent in my 50.000 feet comment m1. As for the type of weapon, which downed McCain into the Hanoi lake, he cannot remember. concede ~ ‘sick puppy’? By the looks of your avatar you must be joking. Interesting that you’ve nothing to contribute other than your own need to attempt censor or free and adult debate.
EddyJ
As I’ve said, the intentions of the then political leadership in America, the CIA and the troops involved in the Vietnam War are indeed in question. Civilians are routinely obliterated in wars, not as you suggest, merely as accidental victims but in manic attempts to diminish enemy morale. Someone with your blinkered perspective obviously cannot grasp the concept of covert objectives, so you throw your hands up in amoral resignation of such slaughter of the innocents, affording a tacit support of the practice under the banner of ‘accepting the reality of war’. Then, typically, you cite excuses such as the placement of enemy defensive weaponry to proportion blame on the victims of US aggression. Nothing new from apologists of war crimes.
Your incredulity that the terrorist attacks of 9/11 should be evoked in conjunction with US foreign aggression is also a predictable reaction from the unthinking American. When your government uses terrorist tactics to further its own
…interests, as in Vietnam, Afghanistan or Iraq, you readily accept the package as ‘an unfortunate reality of war’, so long as it comes in a thin veneer of military respectability. When the same brutality is enacted on your own soil, it’s ‘an unacceptable evil’ that cannot be fathomed by civilized folk. I do not say you hold no value in human life, only that yours is perverse
On the issue of newborns I also find it quite reprehensible that medical professionals in the US are making quick and easy money through routine circumcision of helpless infants. Such an unnecessary and primitive practice. (see my question ‘is infant circumcision a form of child abuse?’)
nosdda we should single out McCain because of the office he holds and was aiming to assume

did McCain Napalm Women & Children during his ‘tour of duty’, and if so is he the best Candidate fo President?

While McCain doesn’t admit to it publicly, he could hardly be unaware of the massive civilian ‘collateral damage’ administered by the Cluster, Napalm and Incendiary bombing he let loose,
The celebrated journalist Harrison Salisbury, in a series of articles for the New York Times in 1966 described the effects of the Hanoi bombings on local civilians, noting that “small villages and hamlets along the route were almost obliterated”. Years later Mc Namara acknowledged that Operation ‘rolling Thunder’ (of which McCain, clocking up 23 missions was an enthusiastic participant) and which unloaded 800 tons of ordinance per day over North Vietnam, caused more than a million deaths and injuries each year from 1965 to 1968. While some of the Vietnamese army had access to an underground network of defensive tunnels civilians bore the brunt of the horrific airborne onslaught

IN RESPONSE: gctradi, the mass slaughter of civilians isn’t merely an incidental act of war, but part of a covert strategy to drain enemy morale. Ali you seem to resent my posting this Question, however you should take into account the gravity of this election and that the choice between politicians is partly due to their characters. So why omit questions regarding the choices these people have made, at crucial times during their service / career? MICHAEL S don’t you consider it correct to refuse to bomb civilians ?

Native English speakers! Please help me with my poor English?

Dear you all,

How do you do? Thank you for taking your time to read this.
I would like you to correct my poor English. I would appreciate if you could change it as fluently as possible.

Thank you for your kindness! I hope you are having a good day!

……

Hawaii is beautiful ^^ I also took many pics when I was there, but I cannot see them any more as my former pc had them and it is out of order. I wish I could see them again, those pics have a lot of memories of Hawaii.

You heard from one of the companies in Japan!? EEE!
Do you think that you can live in Japan? It’s said that to live in another country is hard…and I think it’s true.
It would be really cool that if you live and work in Tokyo, and I hope your Tokyo life would be okay for you.

Hee, you’re a rap singer, aren’t you? That sounds really great.
I’m a terrible singer as well as a terrible dancer. I respect people who can do what I can’t do!

I also want to go to Korea ^^ I’ve never been there, but my sisters and dad went there and they love it!
I would like to visit Korea, HongKong, Vietnam, and Turkey. It would be a great experience if I could go there.

ee! your cousin is from Japan?? so, she can teach and help you with your Japanese ^^
I understand how you feel. I do not speak English much, because I’m embarrassed it,just like your Japanese.
However, it seems that you can speak Japanese very well. You can write mails in Japanese, if you fancy ^^

You think the Japanese young people looks not friendly, I totally agree with you,
Girls are still okay, but boys intimidate me, too ^^; However, I know I was kind of such people when I was younger.
(my ex were such youth as well as his friends) As I am getting older, my thought towards the youth looks not friendly ^^;
My youngest brother is seventeen, so he is a young boy. He is a really serious boy, though.
I think he’s never smoked cigarettes, drank alcohol, changed his hair colour, had any piercings, nearly never be late for his school….etc.
I prefer such a serious guy to a guy who acts cool, mind only his looks. I see you are a serious guy ^^

Thank you for saying that you feel like you can be a tour guide if I ever come there again ^^
I wonder if my host family is fine or not. I’ve not heard anything from them for more than five years.

Should Soldiers ignore their own Conscience and shut up?

There are two kinds of courage in war – physical courage and moral courage. Physical courage is very common on the battlefield. Men and women on both sides risk their lives, place their own bodies in harm’s way. Moral courage, however, is quite rare. According to Chris Hedges, the brilliant New York Times war correspondent who survived wars in Latin America, Africa, the Middle East and the Balkans, “I rarely saw moral courage. Moral courage is harder. It requires the bearer to walk away from the warm embrace of comradeship and denounce the myth of war as a fraud, to name it as an enterprise of death and immorality, to condemn himself, and those around him, as killers. It requires the bearer to become an outcast. There are times when taking a moral stance, perhaps the highest form of patriotism, means facing down the community, even the nation.”
We cannot understand the psychological and moral significance of military resistance unless we recognize the social forces that stifle conscience and human individuality in military life. Gwen Dyer, historian of war, writes that ordinarily, “Men will kill under compulsion. Men will do almost anything if they know it is expected of them and they are under strong social pressure to comply.” “Only exceptional people resist atrocity,” writes psychiatrist Robert Lifton.

How much easier it is to surrender to the will of superiors, to merge into the anonymity of the group. It takes uncommon courage to resist military powers of intimidation, peer pressure, and the atmosphere of racism and hate that drives all imperial wars.

Only the Strongest and BRAVEST of all will resist and stand alone against wrong doing!

Notwithstanding clichés and pieties about support for troops, those who promote war are often the least likely to share the burdens and memories of war when soldiers return. When Ron Kovic, who was paralyzed from the chest down during the war in Vietnam, steered his wheelchair down the aisle of the Republican National Convention in 1972, the delegates spat on him and cheered for Nixon – “Four more years.”

W.D. Erhart, Vietnam veteran and author of Passing Time, never forgot the horrific episodes of his tour in Vietnam. In his first autobiography, he tells a friend about his speech at a Rotary Club. “I even put on a coat and tie and went to the Rotary Club. The Rotary Club, for chrissake. I laid it all out for ‘em. I told ‘em about search and destroy missions, harassment and interdiction fire, winning hearts and minds, all that stuff…Was I ever sharp that day.

“Now listen. You won’t believe this. I got done and nobody said a word. No applause. Nothing. Then this skinny old fart shaped like a cold chisel gets up and says he’s a retired colonel, and he thinks we should keep on pounding those little yellow ******** until they do what we say or we kill ‘em all, and he tells me I can’t be a real veteran because a real veteran wouldn’t go around badmouthing the good old U.S. of A., and the whole place erupts in thunderous applause.”
Welcome home, soldier. Now shut up.

Had the Germans decided to go with Conscience during WW2 I am sure you would agree it would be correct for them to do so, but what about today, and our guys.

Your thoughts…

Post office interview…?

A guy goes to the Post Office to interview for a job. The interviewer asks him, “Are you a Veteran?” The guy says, “Why yes, in fact, I served two tours in Vietnam.”

“Good,” says the interviewer, “That counts in your favor. Do you have any service-related disabilities?”

The guy says, “In fact I am 100% disabled. During a battle, an explosion removed my private parts so they declared me disabled, it doesn’t affect my ability to work, though.”

“Sorry to hear about the damage, but I have some good news for you, I can hire you right now! Our working hours are 8 to 4. Come on in about 10, and we’ll get you started”.

The guy says, “If working hours are 8 to 4, why do you want me to come in at 10?”

“Well, here at the post office, we don’t do anything but sit around and scratch our balls for the first two hours. Don’t need you here for that!”

It’s fair to deport green card holders from the U.S. over minor offenses?

U.S. government moving to deport longtime legal residents with criminal convictions

Ken McLaughlin

kmclaughlin@mercurynews.com

Roger Simmie is no angel.

Twenty years ago, the Mountain View carpenter was convicted of resisting arrest and drug possession. Fifteen years after that, he was found guilty of battering his girlfriend. Three times, he’s been convicted of drunken driving.

But it’s what he didn’t do that got him locked up recently in the Santa Clara County Jail. Simmie, a Scot by birth who fought in Vietnam as a U.S. Marine, never applied for U.S. citizenship.

Now he finds himself facing deportation as one of nearly 400,000 immigrants incarcerated this year ?by the U.S. government. A growing number of noncitizens who have been living in this country as legal permanent residents are learning that run-ins with the law, even minor ones, are translating into life-altering, one-way tickets to homelands they no longer know.

A report last spring from Human Rights Watch found that 1 out of 5 “criminal aliens” deported from 1997 to 2007 had been in the country legally. Many, like Simmie, have known America as home for decades. “I’m living in limbo,” said Simmie, 61, whose friends raised thousands of dollars to hire a lawyer to fight his deportation.

Simmie apologizes for the drunken driving, but he denies he was guilty in the other cases.

After leaving Great Britain with his family as a child and settling in Sunnyvale, Simmie joined the Marines as a teen and did two tours in Vietnam. But he never became a U.S. citizen, in part because his Scottish father felt his son should remain true to his heritage.

http://www.mercurynews.com/ci_14096409?source=most_emailed

Joke – why do you want to come……?

A guy goes to the post office to interview for a job.
The interviewer asks him, “Are you a veteran?”
The guy says,”Why, yes, in fact I served two tours in Vietnam.”
“Good,” says the interviewer. “That counts in your favour. Do you have any service-related dissabilities?”
The guy says, “In fact I am 100% disabled. During a battle an explosion removed my private parts so they declared me disabled. It doesn’t affect my ability to work though.”
“Sorry to hear about the damage, but I have some good news for you. I can hire you right now! Our working hours are 8 to 4. Come on in about 10, and we’ll get you started.”
“The guy says, “If working hours are from 8 to 4, why do you want me to come in at 10?”
“Well, here at the post office, we don’t do anything but sit around and scratch our ba*ls for the first two hours. Don’t need you here for that!”

Anyone Fancy driving overland from Ireland/uk to Austrailia?

Hey,

Looking someone to share the expense and the time to Drive to OZ. The plan is to take off in a Toyota Landcruiser 4×4 around August or October next year.

The route will consist of the following:

France – Germany – Czech Republic – Slovakia – Hungry – Romania – Bulgaria – Turkey – Georgia – Krygastan – Azerbajin – Turkministan – Kazachstan – China – laois – Vietnam – Thailand – Malaysia and ship car to Austrailia.

It’s a journey of a lifetime however there are some large costs assocaited with it, including kitting out the 4×4, feul and accomadation amonst other things.

To cut down on ur costs, I will be paying for the landcruiser (But not modifications) and to cut down on hassle i have already done alot of the prelimanry planning such as budget, maps, visa research and much more.

All of the above such as time of departure, route, and all aspects of the trip are negotiable and open for discussion as this is going to be a team effort.

The trip will need to be approx 4/5 months and longer depending on the route and chill time. Accomadation will be a mix of tents and hostels / hotels.

The ideal person must be open minded and eager to experience new cultures with a real sense of adventure

The problem is i need to source someone for the trip – Does anyone have any ideas how i can get th eword outthere and possibly get someone on board?

the_big_drive2010@yahoo.com

Anyone been to vietnam?

i’m planning a trip there next year, to do a bit of volunteer work and also an organised tour. just wondered what people thought of the country, did you feel safe there, what is the food like etc?
p.s i dont need details about the country, just wanted personal experiences/tips/etc. thanks.

vientnam & cambodia spending money ?

How much money do you think we would need to spend for 3nts cambodia & 11nts vietnam for trip,s meals and drinks & souviners
all flights and hotels & transfer,s and breakfast are payed
is it better to take £ or $us


Powered by Yahoo! Answers